9 June, 2010 by Lim Liat Copyrighted
I was informed by friends that iPad has sold about 2 million units in 2 months. It is now the hot thing for group working together. Corporations and Schools are pushing e-learning and other content for it.
What is so unique about the iPad? We have flat screen touch sensitive device called Window Tablet announced and delivered sometime in 2001-2002. It is almost 9 year earlier. But not much impact it has created.
I need to understand why – why Apple succeeds ?
7 years ago I specially bought a Acer window tablet to try to the pen-input and also to look innovative. Even though Microsoft upgraded the window tablet a few times, improving the hand writing recognition software and others. I am a big user of mind-map and using the leading mindmanager, the king of mind mapping software, that integrated well with the window tablet, I never found it gave any major productivity or ease of use improvement. I always switched back from the flat tablet mode to the standard laptop mode using mouse and keyboard. When the Acer hardware expired, I bought the conventional hp laptop. My daughter was not convinced and she bought the Fujitsu window tablet. Again, she set it aside and is now using a netPC for work requirement, an Apple laptop for home and own use, and an iTouch for mobility.
Now here come iPad with reduced capabilities, and yet it created a big fuss about it.
Let’s compare:
Summarizing iPad over Win-tablet.
See also Understanding The Smartphone Battle – Rise of Apple & Android ...
What is so unique about the iPad? We have flat screen touch sensitive device called Window Tablet announced and delivered sometime in 2001-2002. It is almost 9 year earlier. But not much impact it has created.
I need to understand why – why Apple succeeds ?
7 years ago I specially bought a Acer window tablet to try to the pen-input and also to look innovative. Even though Microsoft upgraded the window tablet a few times, improving the hand writing recognition software and others. I am a big user of mind-map and using the leading mindmanager, the king of mind mapping software, that integrated well with the window tablet, I never found it gave any major productivity or ease of use improvement. I always switched back from the flat tablet mode to the standard laptop mode using mouse and keyboard. When the Acer hardware expired, I bought the conventional hp laptop. My daughter was not convinced and she bought the Fujitsu window tablet. Again, she set it aside and is now using a netPC for work requirement, an Apple laptop for home and own use, and an iTouch for mobility.
Now here come iPad with reduced capabilities, and yet it created a big fuss about it.
Let’s compare:
Features | Win tablet | iPad |
User interface | pen, virtual keyboard | fingers, virtual keyboard |
Software OS | window + | IOS |
Software Apps | mouse, keyboard based serious apps | iPhone type apps(many useful small apps) |
Users | nerds & techies | for happy dummies |
Other Modal IO | speech (poor) | tilting recognition iPad used as steering wheel |
Emotional impact | serious work | fun, joyful work |
Summarizing iPad over Win-tablet.
- Finger is easier & better than pen. It is faster. I always has it with me. No need to pickup pen and loose the pen. Even though pen is more precise than finger.
- Titling recognition, physical motion and feel is always natural and better than clicking options.
- Having fun and joy to do useful thing is better than ‘have to learn’ ‘to be serious’ in doing work (office)
- Laying flat on the table and all eyes can see is good for sharing and working in group.
- Keyboard is an intrusive device for sharing. Hide it when not needed. Have a wireless one for own use.
- For group work, may be useful to applications that
a. join all the iPads physically available to have a bigger sharing workspace for the group.
b. have software that run across multiple iPads joined physically or wirelessly.
- Be natural
use your finger, fingers, sensitive to tilting, twisting, (moving the iPad to do things? Eg. Nintendo’s Wii) - Designed for the happy dummies to do useful work
Using any program should be a joy not a stress.
See also Understanding The Smartphone Battle – Rise of Apple & Android ...
No comments:
Post a Comment